5 Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs (2023)

Training dogs is an essential part of their upbringing. Training your dogs will allow you to develop a closer bond with your precious pooch.

Plus, it will benefit the dog itself by making them safer and by enhancing its well-being. 

Though training is essential, it can be very strenuous. This will definitely be the case if you have a particularly stubborn dog.

These dogs are likely to ignore your commands and resist training. This can make training seem impossible. 

Choosing a good quality training collar will help make this experience much smoother. However, finding the right training collar can be hard.

Fortunately, we have provided several products for you to try out.

Also, to make your shopping experience as straightforward as possible, we have highlighted some of the factors you will need to consider. 

PetSpy Dual Dog Training Shock Collar

PetSpy M919 Dog Training Shock Collar, 1000 Yards, Medium to Large Dogs, with Vibration, Electric Shock and Beep, Waterproof, Remote Trainer (Two Dogs)

The first product in this list is a shock collar from PetSpy. This product is designed for difficult dogs. By using it, you are sure to see a significant improvement in your dog’s behavior.

The collar is designed to give you more control over your dogs, allowing you to correct their stubbornness with 3 different training settings. 


  • Up to 3 dogs: this collar is ideal for people with multiple dogs. You can train your dogs at the same time with just one product. If you are a dog lover, this may be the product for you. 
  • 3 settings: when training your dog, you will need to choose from 3 incredible settings. These are vibration, static shock, and tone. This will give you the power to find the setting that works best for your dog. You can adjust these settings to account for the weight of your pet. 
  • No irritation: nobody likes the thought of their beloved dog feeling irritated. To prevent this problem, PetSpy has featured contact points. These contact points are made out of conductive rubber,  thus reducing the chance of irritation. 
  • Safety: these collars have been colored orange. This vibrant color is super noticeable, meaning that you can keep an eye on your dog. 
  • Waterproof: your dog can still get wet when wearing this collar thanks to its waterproof capabilities. The collar will work even in wet weather conditions. 


  • It may not work for bigger dogs: though this product is made to work for all dogs, we have noticed that it is less successful on some larger dog breeds. If you have a big dog, you may want to be aware of this. If the product does not work on your dog, you may need to return it and purchase a different training collar. 

Also available at: this amazing product can be purchased from other retailers, including:

PetSpy M919 Dog Training Shock Collar, 1000 Yards, Medium to Large Dogs, with Vibration, Electric Shock and Beep, Waterproof, Remote Trainer (Two Dogs)
  • POPULAR DOG TRAINING COLLAR - convert your dog's behavior within days or get your Money Back Guarantee; used by Expert Trainers and first time Dog Owners
  • 3 TRAINING MODES – Tone, Static Shock, and Vibration with 100 adjustable levels for dogs with different weight and sensitivity
  • 1-YEAR REPLACEMENT WARRANTY and 24/7 Customer Support Guarantee - buy it Risk Free; good for all dog breeds and sizes from 10-140 lbs - Rechargeable and Waterproof collar
  • REMOTE COLLAR ACTIVATION allows you to wake up the collar from distance by one push of the button; get Free Dog Training Guide with your order
  • AVOID SKIN IRRITATION with soft rubber contact points technology; Remote collar range is up to 1000 yards - Train up to 3 dogs with 1 controller

SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers

SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer - Rechargeable Training Collar with Shock, Vibrate, and Tone - 500 Yard Range - SD-425XS

Next, this SportDog collar is designed for difficult dogs. This product comes with several impressive features, such as its long-range and waterproof capabilities.

If you are looking for a luxurious product, this collar will be ideal for you. Though the standard product comes in black, you can also get a camouflage-patterned version that looks super cool. 


  • 500-yard range: even when your dog is far away, you can still monitor their behavior thanks to this impressive 500-yard range. This means that you do not have to worry about them running off. Not only does the collar have a considerable range, but it can be used to train 3 dogs at once. 
  • Quick charge: when this product has low battery life, it will inform you. Because of this nifty feature, you do not need to be concerned about the battery dying. This collar is powered by lithium-ion batteries. The quick-charge function will ensure that they are charged within 2 hours. 
  • Submersible up to 25 feet: this waterproof product will still work underwater. It can be submerged up to 25 feet underwater. Consequently, it will work in a variety of terrains and conditions. This makes it a versatile item. 
  • Various settings: like the previous item, you can decide between 3 separate settings. These settings are tone, vibration, and static. Within the static setting, there are 21 different levels to choose from. This results in the collar being an adjustable item that can match your needs. 


  • Cost: compared to some of the other products on the market, this collar is noticeably more expensive. Thus, you should only invest in it if you are willing to spend a little extra on training your dog. If you do not have a big budget, perhaps you should consider some of the other items on this list. 

Also available at: you can also obtain this awesome collar from the following sites:

SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer - Rechargeable Training Collar with Shock, Vibrate, and Tone - 500 Yard Range - SD-425XS
  • HIGHER RANGES OF STIM: Designed for high drive/stubborn dogs that do not respond to lower levels of static stimulation
  • 500 YARD RANGE: e-collar that can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars (SDR-AXS). For dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5" - 22".
  • NO LOOK OPERATION: Designed for ease-of-use and no look operation while offering more levels of stimulation which allows for more customized training.
  • TONE, VIBRATE, AND STIM: This electric e collar offers 21 levels of static stimulation with medium/high ranges. Option to train with vibration (buzz) and tone (beep), too.
  • WATERPROOF: Submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology.

Slopehill Dog Training Collar

Dog Training Collar with 7 Training Modes, 2600Ft Remote Electronic Dog Shock Collar, Electric Shock Collar for Small Medium Large Dogs (Green1)

This dog collar encourages good behavior in your pet whilst also being humane. Perhaps the quality that most sets this collar apart from its rivals is its safety.

This product has been built with safety in mind. This can be observed through the use of a security keypad lock and an LED light.

Because of this, you can use the product with the knowledge that your dog will be safe. Aside from this, the collar also possesses other standard features such as waterproof capability and long battery life. 


  • Affordable: when compared to other dog training collars, this product is quite cheap. This budget-friendly will be well suited to people who are unable to spend a lot of money on their dog training products. 
  • Security keypad lock: to stop you from misclicking a button, this keypad has a useful security pad. 
  • LED light: the collar comes with a built-in LED light and reflective strap. As a consequence, you will be able to locate your dog even when it is dark. This makes it well suited to people who take their dogs walking at night. 
  • Size adjustable: you can alter the size of this collar to perfectly fit your dog. It can be adjusted from 8 inches to 26 inches. Whether you have a big or small dog, this item will fit them. It is suitable for dogs that weigh between 5 to 140 pounds. This covers a wide range of dog breeds. 


  • Not usable for bigger dogs: though this collar is suitable for use on a wide range of dog sizes, it should not be used on dogs that weigh more than 140 pounds. While most dogs will be under this weight limit, some bigger dog breeds, such as Great Danes, will exceed it. 

Dog Training Collar with 7 Training Modes, 2600Ft Remote Electronic Dog Shock Collar, Electric Shock Collar for Small Medium Large Dogs (Green1)
  • 7 training modes: This waterproof dog shock collar with Beep, Vibration, Low shock level, High shock level, Shock lock, Light and Keypad lock modes, you can use it to teach a dog basic obedience commands and solve an uncontrollable dog's behaviour problem
  • Shock locked mode is convenient for you to use only vibration and beep mode. Low shock(0~50), high shock(51~99), kepad lock modes help you adjust the accurate and comfortable static level for your dog and prevents any misoperation on the remote.
  • This training collar receiver is 100% waterproof, your dog can wear it when swimming, raining, and doing outdoor activities. The remote is not waterproof.
  • Slopehill dog shock collar come with a size adjustable collar strap, length from 8 to 26inches, fits dogs from 8 to 140 lbs
  • Any problem, contact +1 (732) 762-2943, we will always be here to help you.

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar with Remote

Remote Dog Training Collar,Night Light,Removable Shock,Vibrate,Anti Bark,Beep Mode - Hunting Standard ¾ Mile Long Range Waterproof E Collar,Train 3 Dogs if Extra Collars Bought,Big,Large,Medium 15lbs+

The penultimate collar in this list is a brilliant item from Pet Resolve. It has several different modes. It also has lots of other desirable features, including memory settings, an impressive range, and a handy light.

If you have a stubborn dog, the settings on this collar will enable you to locate a setting that modifies your dog’s behavior. 


  • Light mode: you can use this nifty light when it is dark outside. This means you can still walk your dog during the winter months and at night. Few dog collars have this useful feature, aside from the previous item. 
  • Sound mode: this collar has a unique feature, which allows you to use noise to change the behaviors of your dog. 
  • Memory settings: this collar has a memory setting that enables you to remember the settings that you last used. Consequently, you will not need to reprogram the controls every time you use them. 
  • Hunting standard: this collar is a professional standard, used in hunting scenarios. As a result, you can trust that it is a good quality item. 
  • Durable: the collar is extremely durable. It is waterproof, allowing you to submerge it underwater. It can be used when it is raining and means that your dog can still play in puddles. 


  • Not long-lasting: some people have noticed that the training collars stopped working after a while. Though we did not experience this issue, regardless this could be an issue that you face. If you are looking for a long-lasting product, you may want to consider some other options. 

Also Available at: you can also get this collar from here:

Remote Dog Training Collar,Night Light,Removable Shock,Vibrate,Anti Bark,Beep Mode - Hunting Standard ¾ Mile Long Range Waterproof E Collar,Train 3 Dogs if Extra Collars Bought,Big,Large,Medium 15lbs+
  • FANTASTIC NEW UPGRADE SINCE MAY= 4.7* + EXTRA LONG & REMOVE THE SHOCK PRONGS + NO STANDBY MODE ALWAYS READY + ANTI BARK & LIGHT NIGHT MODE! Is your dog misbehaving and you want a well behaved pet with minimal fuss? The Pet Resolve system is the perfect solution to train upto 3 dogs for a range of desirable behaviors. Don't let your dog get side-tracked by other animals or misbehave in public. Teach your canine companion how to act properly with arguably the top training collar on the market!
  • SUPER LONG RANGE AND MEMORY; forget other dog training collars which use cheap plastic that breaks when you drop it and are designed for small spaces and yards, our e collar dog training system is of the highest quality and has a super long 3/4 Mile range (1312 yards suitable for hunting dogs) for easy outdoor training covering the widest areas! You certainly get what you pay for with training collars and unfortunately most cheap collars won't last long!
  • VARIABLE SHOCK & VIBRATION LEVELS, ANTI BARK & LIGHT for NIGHT MODE; train up to 3 dogs at once (additional collars required) with up to 10 levels of continuous or momentary shock (hold down button to shock for 1 up to 8 seconds, ideal for emergencies!) vibrations, or beeps, for safe, efficient training, allowing you to teach your dog a range of commands. Sometimes it only takes one click of a button to completely change the behavior of your dog and the vibration button does the job for most!
  • WATERPROOF CONSTRUCTION; does your dog love to run outside or swim? Unlike cheap collars, our training system is completely waterproof (remote splash proof) and can be fully submerged without damage! Most other collars fail in the rain, we provide shock collars dogs can actually swim in all year round! It's worth noting that this collar doesn't go in to standby mode like most, meaning that it's ready to use when you actually need it!
  • ULTRA LONG LASTING BATTERY & WARRANTY for LARGE, MEDIUM AND SMALL DOGS OVER 15LBS; our training collar is powered by a super high capacity rechargeable Li-ion battery, fully charged in 2 hours (Charge above 32 fahrenheit in the house) , for long lasting training without having to constantly change batteries! You also get a warranty included no questions asked and World Class Customer Service!

PetJett Prong Collar for Dogs

PetJett Prong Collar for Dogs - No Pull Choke Collar for Dogs, Pinch Collar for Dogs, Dog Training Collar & Dog Walking Tool for Small, Medium, or Large Breed - Stainless Steel Metal Dog Choker Chain

Finally, this product from PetJett is great for people who are looking for a more budget-friendly and low-tech training collar.

Perfect for disobedient pooches, you can easily modify your dog’s behavior with this collar.

The fact that it is less technologically advanced than the other 4 options means that you do not need to bother with recharging your collar’s batteries. Instead, you can simply use the collar as it is. 


  • Durable: this product is designed to last you for a long time. Built from stainless steel, it will not be easily broken or damaged. The sturdy collar is also built to be water-resistant and rust-free. 
  • POM buckle snap clip: this clip is super straightforward to use. This will save you time and energy when you have to put the collar on and off your dog. 
  • 4 sizing options: you can buy this product in 4 different sizes. Choose from small, medium, large, and extra-large. This allows you to find the ideal size for your dog. 
  • Effective: this collar will not hurt your dog. Instead, it will create a light pinching feeling that imitates the discipline of a mother dog. This method will successfully correct your dog’s bad behavior. 
  • Chrome-plated links: the links of the collar are crafted to be gentle on your dog. They have silicone caps that will ensure the collar stays in place without being harmful to your dog. 


  • Difficult to adjust: though this product can be adjusted, some customers have complained that the item is difficult to alter. Though we did not experience this problem, you should nonetheless be aware of it. Due to this, it is important to purchase the right-sized collar. 

PetJett Prong Collar for Dogs - No Pull Choke Collar for Dogs, Pinch Collar for Dogs, Dog Training Collar & Dog Walking Tool for Small, Medium, or Large Breed - Stainless Steel Metal Dog Choker Chain
  • Recommended for Unruly & Disobedient Dogs: Walking your dogs can be tough when they're constantly pulling on the leash or barking at passersby. Our pronged training collar for dogs is the right tool to communicate with your puppy effectively. It's designed to provide a gentle pinching sensation on your dog's neck as you gently pull their leash. It mimics the correction that a mother dog naturally gives to puppies—making it easier for them to understand when their behavior is unacceptable
  • Safe & Effective Dog Training Tool: Whether you own a German Shepherd, a Pitbull, a Bulldog, a Beagle, or a Rottweiler, our prong collar for dogs is safe for any breed! Its evenly spaced prongs prevent any injury by allowing for an even distribution of pressure around your dog's neck. It lets you safely correct offensive or dangerous behavior without causing any pain. Completely safe, it won't restrict your dog's airway as you pull the collar that's why dog trainers love and recommend it!
  • Built to Last for Years: Made from high-quality stainless steel, this durable pronged collar has a rust-free and water-resistant construction that will provide years of use. Ideal not just for professional dog trainers, our easy-to-use collar includes easy-to-follow instructions inside the box for hassle-free use of every dog owner! Our chain collar comes with 4 extra links and 8 rubber caps to let you quickly adjust the collar's size for a comfortable, precise fit around your dog's neck.
  • Designed to Prioritize Your Pet's Comfort: Featuring chrome-plated links equipped with soft silicone caps, our anti-barking, anti-pulling collar stays in place as your dog moves. The smooth, rounded prongs won't dig into a canine's skin—eliminating the risk of possible skin irritation. Built with a quick-release POM buckle snap clip, you'll have no trouble putting on or removing the collar, even from an active dog! Also constructed with a sturdy D-ring, it allows secure attachment of a leash.
  • The Better Way to Train Your Dog: Walking your dog will be a walk in the park when you have our dog pinch collar! Unlike static collars, the self-limiting action of our Prong Collar protects your dog's trachea from damage when used correctly. Ideal for aggressive dogs, this temporary tool makes it easy to communicate with them and train them to be more obedient. Enjoy morning walks with your best buddy and improve your relationship with your furry friends by clicking 'Add to Cart' today!

Buyer’s Guide

best training collar for stubborn dogs

After reading through our product suggestions, you will probably think that you are in a good position to begin buying a training collar for your strong-willed dog.

After all, this list will have highlighted the advantages and disadvantages of arguably the best products on the market. As a result, you will now have a deeper knowledge of what features to look out for and who to avoid. 

You should bear in mind that shopping for high-quality dog training collars can actually be harder than it initially seems. This is because there are multiple factors that you will need to take into consideration.

These factors will determine whether a collar is right for you or not. Luckily, we have selected some of the key considerations below. Please think about these points before you begin shopping. 


Dog training collars are sold at a wide range of price points. While some are quite costly, others will be more affordable. Generally, more expensive collars tend to have more features.

However, this does not necessarily mean that expensive collars are better than cheaper ones. For instance, the Slopehill training collar is a super safe and efficient product that is sold at quite a low price. 

In order to stop yourself from spending too much on a training collar, it is advised that you think about the amount of money that you are willing to spend.

Set yourself a price limit if you are on a tight budget. Remember to search online stores with a filter that will not include collars that are outside of your price range. You can also order your searches from the lowest-priced product to the highest. 


While a lot of people will not be overly bothered by the appearance of their dog collars, others will be.

Some people will want their collars to come in certain colors or styles. In some cases, this can also impact the use of the collar.

For instance, brighter colors will be easier to see. Therefore, there is a lower chance of you losing your dog.

The PetSpy collar is an example of this, coming in a distinctive orange color. Also, some collars may have reflective strips that can make seeing your dog easier in dark conditions. 

Safety Features

To many people, the safety of their dogs is a top priority. Rightly so! Therefore, it is important that their collars contain features that promote safety.

Collars should be comfortable for your dogs. Otherwise, the collar is unsafe and potentially harmful to the dog. An example of a useful safety feature is the LED light contained in the Slopehill collar. 

Different Modes

As you may have observed, most training collars contain different modes. These modes allow you to customize your collar, finding the right setting for your pet.

Products with lots of modes and settings will be best suited to stubborn dogs since you can choose a setting that best discourages this destructive behavior. 


When investing in a dog training collar, you should think about the charging capabilities of the product. Some products will come with longer battery life than others.

These products will need to be charged less often. Products that have a limited battery life will need to be charged frequently. You will need to remember to charge the product before you go out.

Thankfully, some products have reminder features that inform you when the product has a low charge. Moreover, some collars will take longer to charge than others. 

Waterproof Capabilities 

Though most training collars are waterproof, not all will be. It is important that you get a waterproof collar. Otherwise, you will be unable to walk your pet in rainy or snowy weather.

Furthermore, your dog will be unable to play in puddles or any larger bodies of water.

If your dog is prone to doing this, it is advised that you find a collar that is fully waterproof. This should be included in the description of an item, such as its online listing. 


An additional feature that you will need to consider is the size of the collar. While some collars are adjustable, others are not.

Because of this, you may need to measure the size of your dog’s neck. Doing so may enable you to find a collar size that works for your dog. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Training Collars Good For Dogs?

Training collars are somewhat controversial. While some argue that this negative reinforcement can alter the behavior of dogs, others claim that they are inhumane.

Some people have found that more positive based behavior modification methods are better.

For example, giving treats to dogs after they have been well behaved can encourage them to develop good behavior. If your dog is particularly stubborn, training collars may be successful. 

Can Training Collars Make Dogs Aggressive? 

In most cases, dog collars will not make dogs aggressive. Many users do not find this to be the case.

However, studies have found that training collars can make dogs angry and aggressive. This may be because the shocks can cause dogs to develop anxiety. 

How Do Training Collars Work?

Usually, training collars are controlled by a handheld remote. Using this device, you can send signals to the collar worn by the dog.

The collar will respond depending on what mode it has been set to. For example, it may use vibrations to alter the behavior of the dog. 

Leave a Reply